Skip to main content

Are teachers like priests? Is it time to start believing in ourselves?

U6mtJlIakq

I keep track of GapingVoid and this blog post, combined with a few other events this week, have made me think.  I pondered briefly on this subject back in 2011.  Hugh’s main point in the post above is that we’re all looking for new stuff to believe in.

Following Hugh’s format, here are a few ingredients:

  • One of my favourite tracks contains this lyric:

‘Believe in me, Help me believe in anything, I want to be someone who believes’

  • Thinking about digital exercise books over at the Microsoft School’s Blog.
  • Some excellent blog posts defending Gove and his policies by Tom Bennett, Andrew Old and Kevin Bartle that I tend to agree with.  Having been dragged up in the Welsh Valleys as the son of a mining engineer, I’m a life long Labour party supporter. If you haven’t already, read them. In essence, we have to stop saying that Gove’s educational policy is pants because it originates from Gove. This post isn’t as good as any of these.
  • Planning some reaction and getting students involved in hacking / mashing up the ‘new’ National Curriculum. Whenever it turns up.

Hugh asks what ‘new certainties’ our work is bringing to the world.  I often like teaching to the priesthood.  I was an altar boy until my early teens and went to Catholic Schools.  It seems to me that many teachers loose their ‘faith’ in teaching much like a priest may question their belief in God.  There’s nothing wrong with a little naval gazing now and again, however it’s starting to get silly.  The problem is of course that our figurehead changes often.  Therefore, it’s important to develop an individual core set of principles or beliefs of what education is. 

The only ‘new certainty’ that I know of is that there is a disconnect between political rhetoric and intentions and what actually happens many times removed from Whitehall.

We attack Gove and the Government for destroying education. Really?  I can only ever tell stories based on my own experiences so,

  • I was told that my first Ofsted inspection would be horrendous. It wasn’t.
  • I was told that BSF would revolutionise my teaching. It didn’t.
  • I was told that the cancelation of BSF was a disaster. It wasn’t.
  • Every time the Ofsted framework changes, I’m told that it will be a disaster. It hasn’t been.
  • I was told that Controlled Assessment would be bad for learning and destroy GCSE Geography.  It didn’t.
  • When the curriculum changed last time, it was going to transform teaching. It didn’t.
  • I’m often told that accountability and driving up standards will destroy creativity in the classroom. It hasn’t.

I could go on.  Maybe I haven’t been doing this for long enough. Maybe I’m just a muppet with no idea. But, what I believe is that by acting professionally and creating, adapting, subverting and changing our curriculum, teaching and learning will get better. 

Every change brings opportunity.

Is the problem with education that we are all looking for a leader to tell us what good learning looks like? Are teachers too afraid to define it themselves and act upon it? Are we, as a profession, content with shouting and moaning or are we brave enough to do something about it? 

How many of the sceptics present an alternative reality?

My point?  I like listening to the background noise and trying to understand the arguments. However, my focus is on the staff and young people that I work with.  I’ve said this before, but I see it as my job to twist whatever pops out of the political machine for good.

Comments

  1. Interesting
    Thanks for posting

    We're more likely to go down a Google Docs route than a Windows one...

    But I do think it's tough sometimes without considerable self belief.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Super to have found your blog, I am thinking of becoming a teacher - a geography teacher - but have been warned that teachers just have to comply with the system and there is no scope for inspiring the kids and just going off-lesson every so often.
    I love your take on the teaching system, I feel a little better about persuing my passion now, thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for the comment. It's a great job :-)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What makes a learning experience profound? Personal reflections and possible implications for classroom practice.

I have recently begun a Leadership Pathways journey.  As part of the first core day, we were asked to reflect on a profound learning experience. This got me thinking about how many profound learning experiences I have both been involved in, and how many I have been able to give to others.  Our group came up with a huge long list, but these are my five. Emotional Connected Demanding Reflective Collaborative As always, these are personal thoughts and quite mixed up.  I put them here so that I can look back on them (plus they’d get lost inside my world-cup-free brain) 1. Emotional I can’t think of a time where deep learning hasn’t engaged my emotions.  From being awe inspired to that tingle feeling when a student gets a light bulb moment.  From this-is-the-happiest-day-ever, to I-think-I’m-about-to die.  How often do we engage the emotions of those we teach?  Here, I would argue that having a safe learning environment is not always conducive to profound

The danger of Teaching and Twitter conversations: poorly formed bipolar arguments.

Sometimes in life, there really are only two options.  Get the wrong one and you can look like a muppet.  Take this useful sign for the toilets in Morocco.  I successfully navigated it, choosing the right option.  The result? No egg on my face.  As a mountain leader, there are many right or wrong decisions that I’ve faced, as there are all over life.  It’s not a good idea to let inexperienced young people walk themselves down Snowdon.  They may die or be seriously injured.  If someone is showing the signs and symptoms of hyperthermia, you need to treat it fast in a specified way.  There is no real arguing with this sign: Other options are less obvious.  Take this sign recently spotted near to where I live: Now, I wouldn’t consider sleeping in a bin.  However, faced with a sub-zero night, I could see the appeal.  The danger? Being tipped into one of those huge lorries with a compactor. (by the way, I only really considered all of this thanks to questions from my four year old boy).

Banned Word Board

Today I want to share some simple ideas that I have found to be very effective in the classroom. I can't say that they are my own original ideas, although I have played around with them. The first is the Banned word Board. This is a simple display in the classroom that lists a number of words that are not allowed to be used by pupils in their written or oral answers. The effect has been an increase in the quality of written work, and I have almost made comments such as 'Sir it's simple, the stuff just affects the thing and causes people problems'. Pupils are now more able to use specific language, something that is vital especially at GCSE. I have had to make a few modifications, such as the introduction of 'Heavenly Words' This is an additional display placed on the ceiling. I found this necessary as pupils needed some stimulus in finding replacement words. After advice received after posting the idea on the SLN forum , I have also introduced semi-banned words